Friday, March 10, 2006

New Grace Period for Filing LM-10s

> >
>
>
> The Labor Department's Office of Labor-Management Standards
>announced March 7 that many employers will have extra time to file LM-10
>forms disclosing payments and gifts made to unions and their officers and
>employees.
> OLMS said employers whose fiscal year ends Dec. 31 will have until May 15 to file fiscal 2005 LM-10s. Normally, LM-10s must be filed 90 days after the
>end of an employer's fiscal year; thus, organizations whose fiscal year
>ends Dec. 31 normally would have to file LM-10s by March 31.
>
> A separate March 7 advisory OLMS included an updated list of
>frequently asked questions regarding the LM-10, including who must file it
>and what must be disclosed.
>
> Under the Labor-Management Reporting and Disclosure Act, employers
>must report any payments and loans made to unions and union officials, as
>well as payments to employees designed to persuade them regarding their
>bargaining and representation rights, and payments to labor relations
>consultants.
>
> In announcing the grace period, OLMS said it received many inquiries
>following its last update of the frequently asked questions in November
>2005. The new guidance is
>designed to address some of the questions raised, but the Labor Department
>acknowledged that employers utilizing the new guidance would have only a
>short period of time to incorporate the answers prior to the normal March
>31 deadline. Thus, while the department does not have the authority to
>extend statutory deadlines, OLMS said it would use its discretion and not
>take any enforcement measures against employers with fiscal years ending
>Dec. 31 as long as they file by May 15.
>
> The November guidance from OLMS also said that as an incentive to
>get employers to file LM-10s for the first time, organizations filing their
>fiscal 2005 forms on time would not have to file delinquent forms for such
>years. Under the new extension, employers with fiscal years ending Dec. 31
>can file their LM-10s for the first time by May 15 and not have to file
>back LM-10s, the department said.
>
>
> Clarification of Who Is 'Employer.'
>
> The new list of frequently asked questions includes new guidance on
>when businesses are considered employers for LM-10 purposes. For example,
>it clarifies that any person acting directly or indirectly as an agent of
>an employer is covered. Thus, an individual hired by a financial services
>firm to generate new business and who provides a union official with season
>tickets to sporting events would have to file an LM-10, even if that
>individual does not employ anyone.
> In addition, the guidance now states that outside attorneys retained
>by unions "will in most, if not all, cases" have to file LM-10s. A law firm
>providing representation to an employer for collective bargaining purposes
>also would have to disclose the value of lunches provided to union
>officials during bargaining, subject to the $250 annual de minimis
>limitation. However, sole proprietors generally are not employers for LM-10
>purposes, according to the guidance.
>
> The guidance also specifies that certain payments from employers to
>unions and union officials are not reportable if the union reimburses the
>employer for those payments. Thus, a law firm that provides a meal during a
>meeting to prepare for collective bargaining would not have to report the
>value of that meal if the food costs are billed to the union, the
>department said. If one employer reimburses another for a reportable
>payment, the entity responsible for the final cost must file the LM-10, it
>added.
>
> The department added language to the guidance making it clear that
>employers must disclose otherwise reportable payments to union employees
>who earn $10,000 or less per year, even though such employees do not have
>to be mentioned by name on LM-2 financial disclosure reports for unions.
>The guidance also clarified that employers do not have to report payments
>to individuals who are officers or employees of unions composed entirely of
>state, county, or municipal employees and thus not covered by the LMRDA.
>
> OLMS also introduced new exemptions for reporting payments and gifts
>to union officials associated with widely attended gatherings, which the
>department defined as events that many people attend, including a
>substantial number with no union connection. Employers that sponsor such an
>event and spend $20 or less per attendee do not have to report such gifts,
>nor do they have to track such payments. In addition, an employer can
>sponsor up to two widely held events per year and spend up to $125 per
>participant without reporting or tracking such expenses.
>
> The $125 exemption also applies to union officials. They can attend
>up to two events not costing more than $125 each without reporting the
>benefit on LM-30s, which are the corresponding forms filed by union
>officers and employees. In addition, such payments would not count toward
>the de minimis threshold for LM-30 purposes; thus, if a union official
>attended two employer-sponsored events that cost $120 each and also
>received a reportable payment of $50, he or she would still not have to
>file an LM-30 because of de minimis rules.
>
> However, OLMS cautioned that if an employer does not know at the
>beginning of its fiscal year that it will hold no more than two such
>events, it should keep records of its expenses and attendee lists.
>
> OLMS added language to its LM-10 guidance specifying how such forms
>are different from LM-30s. For example, employers filing LM-10s must
>disclose payments to unions officers, agents, shop stewards, and other
>representatives, while union officers and employees must file LM-30s if
>they--or a spouse or minor child--receive a reportable payment. In
>addition, employers filing LM-10s must disclose any payment to any union
>employee. Meanwhile, a union employee who is a member of the clerical staff
>would not have to report the receipt of such a payment on an LM-30.
>
> As for past-due forms, the guidance said that in order to comply
>with the department's grace period offer, employers were required to file
>an LM-10 for fiscal 2005. Now, however, employers can take advantage of the
>grace period even if they did not make any reportable payments for fiscal
>2005. Rather than filing a blank form, employers should maintain records
>demonstrating that they identified no reportable interest after making a
>good-faith effort to track such payments, according to OLMS.
>
> The new guidance is available on the Web at
>http://www.dol.gov/esa/regs/compliance/olms/lm10_advisory.htm.
>
>
>
> >
>
>
>_____________________________________________________________________
>>

Thursday, March 02, 2006

Lobbyists and Associations Need Fiduciary Insurance

A new rash of lawsuits are on the horizon.

Clients and members of associations are, in light of recent scrutiny of lobbyists activities, becoming more concerned about how their funds are being spent in DC, whether directly or through their lobbyists. Lobbyists who handle or direct client's funds may be determined to be fiduciaries for their clients. The SEC, the Courts, and other regulatory bodies are rapidly expanding the definition of a fiduciary.

For lawyers this is usually not a problem, most Professional E&O policies cover fiduciary exposures, although if I were a lawyer-lobbyist I would want to make sure there is not an exclusion in my firm's policy for fiduciary responsibilities. However there are many lobbyists who are not lawyers or lawyers who do not carry professional E&O who have this exposure. They direct the client where to spend money or do it themselves.

The same goes for associations who use their member's funds to promote certain causes in many ways. There is an exposure to a claim that funds were not used in a "prudent" manner. The association's assets or lobbyist assets can very quickly be used up defending such a claim. The McLaughlin Company is developing with its carriers a low-priced exclusive product targeting lobbyists, but we also think that the exposure to associations is possibly even greater. Although the exposure is even greater, most evidence indicates that less than 10% of associations carry fiduciary coverage. A "prudent" association Board of Directors should consult with its Independent agent about fiduciary coverage.

As always we would both really appreciate your thoughts and insights.

Wednesday, March 01, 2006

Professional Advisors = Fiduciaries -- Are you insured?

Scandals that have rocked the financial services industry and have raised awareness among investors of the potential for conflicts of interest, misrepresentations and other alleged wrongdoings by investment advisers, actuaries, brokers and money managers. As a result, professionals increasingly are subject to lawsuits alleging various forms of misfeasance, including breach of fiduciary duty, misrepresentation or omission of material facts, conflict of interest and fraud. Lawsuits of this kind also entail the possibility of personal liability.

Financial planners, investment advisers, actuaries, securities dealers, registered representatives and others in the financial field often act in a fiduciary role.
Recently, the SEC has moved toward treating all brokers as fiduciaries, as well.
Those advisers who deal with pension, employee benefit and other benefit plans are subject to additional fiduciary duties under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974. In our litigious times, even the most circumspect professionals may find themselves sued for breach of fiduciary duty or other misfeasance. Insurance is therefore of paramount importance as a defense against fiduciaries’ liability exposure.

Due diligence on the insurance front entails more than simply the purchase of the right kinds of policies. Policyholders must be aware of common provisions routinely inserted by insurance providers that raise the likelihood of coverage denials in time of need. Over the past few years, there has been a significant restriction in the insurance marketplace for investment advisers and asset managers. Many companies pulled out altogether, and those that remained increased their pricing and retentions significantly while at the same time carving out important areas of coverage. Recently, however, the underwriting conditions have improved. Companies that withdrew from the market have stepped back in, and new entrants have begun to surface. With this opening up of the marketplace has come a reduction of the pricing scale, somewhat lower retentions and a willingness to consider broadening the scope of certain coverage.

Although underwriters remain stringent regarding the amount of limits to which they are willing to commit, the addition of these new markets allows for the layering of much higher limits than has recently been available. There are significant differences among the various insurers’ policy forms.

Although the market has improved carriers continue to try and reduce their exposure by addining exclusionary language. The following is a sampling of some actions taken by insurance companies of which to be aware:

* Limiting regulatory-investigation coverage.

* Widening the exclusions for personal profit and wrongful acts.

* Narrowing the severability language of their policies, which protects innocent officers from the
wrongful conduct of other officers.
* Issuing specific additional exclusions, such as market timing and late trading.

Since the policy forms, exclusions and available endorsements are changing frequently, it is advisable that someone well versed in financial insurance, like The McLaughlin Company, review your current policies.

Tuesday, February 21, 2006

Will you serve on our Board of Directors?

Playing golf with your Saturday foursome you are asked, " John, I think you are just what I need. Recently, we have been advised to add independent individuals to my company's board, and I think you would be perfect. What do you say?"

John is very interested, but knows that going on a Board is not the social club it used to be. There are lots of questions John should ask before saying yes including checking with his personal independent insurance agent who should say:

A prospective director should evaluate the company’s D&O insurance program and consider buying personal director’s liability insurance.

In evaluating the corporate D&O policy, questions to ask include the following.

1. Is the company carrying sufficient D&O insurance in light of increased risks to independent directors?

2. Do severability provisions or policy exclusions leave individuals personally exposed? Limited or no severability means that the entire board of
directors, who might be included in a potential lawsuit, might not have coverage regardless of any individual’s own actions.

3. How experienced and financially stable are the insurers of the D&O program?

4. Does the company’s D&O policy cover the company as an entity in addition to directors and officers? Entity coverage erodes protection for individuals.

5. What is the effect of bankruptcy on the D&O policy? Entity coverage can tie a policy up in bankruptcy court.

6. Is the company following corporate governance best practices?

In addition, John should consider Personal Director’s Liability Coverage
An existing or prospective director should also consider personal director’s liability coverage. Personal director’s liability insurance is a coverage that protects individuals and their personal assets in the event that they are sued as a result of their directorship activities.

If the response is when he starts asking these questions is " we don't need D&O insurance its expensive and a waste of money." John, should join another foursome.

Tuesday, February 14, 2006

DOL's latest on reporting requirements

WHAT CAN EMPLOYERS EXPECT IN THE FUTURE FROM DOL?

DOL has initiated rulemaking on the LM-30 instructions. It is anticipated that parallel rules will be developed for the LM-10 employer reports. Several DOL proposals would eliminate exemptions and significantly increase the reporting requirements of employers. For example:

(1) DOL proposes to require reporting on the LM-30 payments received by union officers and employees for work performed for the union — e.g., a “no docking” arrangement under which a union steward or union officer resolves grievances on an “as needed” basis while being paid regular wages or a “union leave” arrangement whereby a union officer continues to be paid a salary by the employer while working fulltime on union business. Both the employee and the employer would have to report all payments other than those for “productive work”.

(2) DOL proposes to eliminate the de minimis exception altogether.

Friday, January 20, 2006

A Respite

Need a respite from serious Insurance and Risk Management discussion? Go to http://writingwomen.blogspot.com or http://pickledpigsfeet.blogspot.com. The authors will tickle your funny bone and calm you like a slow moving brook.

Saturday, January 14, 2006

Hail!!


Our Chairman, John T. Pappas, a Redskins season ticket holder for more than 50 years, had an opportunity on Friday to share his enthusiasm for our team as he sang Hail to the Redskins for News4.

Thursday, January 05, 2006

West Virginia Moves to a Private Workers Compensation System

On January 1, 2006, the West Virginia Workers’ Compensation Commission will cease to exist and be replaced by BrickStreet Mutual Insurance. At first, BrickStreet will be the exclusive insurer in West Virginia. As such, it will be one of the largest insurers in West Virginia. This change leaves only four other exclusive state funds to finance workers' compensation benefits (Ohio, North Dakota, Wyoming and Washington).

The Executive Director of the West Virginia Workers’ Compensation Commission will be the President and CEO of the new insurance company. In a very novel twist to corporate covernance of a mutual insurer, 5 of the 7 Board members are elected by employers insured by the company.

The timing of the transition to private insurance will be as follows: on July 1, 2008, West Virginia’s insurance market will open to all private carriers licensed to do business in West Virginia. BrickStreet will continue to be the sole source of workers’ compensation coverage for all state agencies, boards, commissions, and higher education through 2012. Starting in 2013, these state agencies can purchase coverage from any insurance carrier.

West Virginia allows for a regulated self insured status. This year self insured employers could also adjudicate their own claims. Benefit levels for injured workers remain as before, as will administrative review of claims payments and disputed claims. The regulation of private insurance and self insurance will be transferred to the West Virginia Insurance Commission.

Thursday, December 29, 2005

Medicare Prescription Drug Coverage

Beginning January 1, 2006, prescription drug coverage will be available to all Medicare recipients. You can help your friends and family members enrolled in Medicare consider this important new benefit by making certain they have the necessary information about it and how to enroll. Enrollment started November 15, 2005 and will run through May 15, 2006.

If you have a family member or friend whom you would like to assist through this decision-making process, there are five simple steps you should follow:

Understand the basics of Medicare Prescription Drug Coverage
Determine how your friend or family member gets prescription coverage today
Gather some important information
Review the plan choices
Point out to them how to enroll

Additional information about the new Medicare Prescription Drug Coverage, including a webcast of a television program that recently aired on CNBC entitled the "National Day of Conversation: Friends and Family First," can be obtained online by visiting www.medicare.gov or by calling 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227) or TTY 1-877-486-2048. Operators are available 24/7 and can walk you, your friend, or your family member through the Plan Finder and provide personalized help in comparing and choosing a plan.

Wednesday, December 28, 2005

2005 -- Year of Challenges and Accomplishments

In its 75th year, The McLaughlin Company took significant strides to better serve its clients, and to prepare itself for the rapidly evolving world of Risk Management and Insurance. Besides the daily challenges of meeting and placing its clients insurance needs, The McLaughlin Company prepared for the future in several significant areas:

Union Liability Insurance – The McLaughlin Company negotiated with the carriers of this insurance product several improvements in the policies including the ability of the insured to select its own counsel, broader coverage, and reduced premiums for Individual Labor Leaders. This product is essential to a Union in these days of heightened scrutiny by DOL, privacy concerns about Union membership lists, and the plethora of employment related practices claims.
Creative Risk Management – The Sarbanes – Oxley Act of 2002 has had a tremendous impact on an enterprises’ risk management function. Enterprises have an obligation to establish and maintain an adequate internal control structure and assess annually its internal controls. Lack of controls in certain insurance areas can lead to financial mistatement. Creative Risk Management, a division of The McLaughlin Company, is fully staffed to provide risk management services to new and existing clients.
Workers Compensation Insurance – This year, The McLaughlin Company, partnered with a database company to assist it in analyzing our client’s workers compensation claims. This database has proven to reduce many workers compensation premiums by 30 percent and insure that a client is never overpaying for workers compensation insurance.

Interactive Website – In 2005, The McLaughlin Company’s website received a completely new facelift. This new website allows existing clients to fill out applications on-line, provides an immediate vehicle for visitors to access up to date information on insurance products and trends in the industry, and gives new clients immediate availability to a trained insurance professional.
New Markets – This year, The McLaughlin Company, added several new insurance companies to its already long list of outstanding companies it represents. It has also developed markets for difficult to place coverages such as political organizations, technology companies, training funds, i.e. Finally, as markets tightened for some products The McLaughlin Company partnered with insurance companies to insure that its clients would always have certain products available. When there is a difficulty getting insurance coverage, The McLaughlin Company is the place to go.
Employee Benefits – In 2005, The McLaughlin Company entered into an association with a team of specialists in the area of employee benefit programs, group and individual life, health and disability programs. The McLaughlin Company is able to provide its clients significant savings and expertise in designing employee benefit programs.
Identity Theft – The McLaughlin Company saw a need for its personal lines clients to protect them when they become victims of identity theft. Through a program with St. Paul/Travelers every McLaughlin Company personal lines client is provided identity theft coverage free of charge.

The McLaughlin Company has a rich history of looking for better ways to provide service and products for new and existing clients. The year 2006 will present new challenges and we are prepared to meet them.

Monday, November 21, 2005

Workers Wanted?

Bt 2010, many skilled workers will have retired and there will be too few active workers to replace and support them, even drawing on the dwindling labor resources of the Far East that have provided outsourcing labor. To fill the labor pool employers will increasingly turn to older workers, married women, and disabled individuals.

According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the number of workers aged 55 or older is expected to grow 50 Percent between 2005 and 2012.

Wednesday, November 16, 2005

New ISO-CGL Changes Raise Concerns For Additional Insureds and Indemnitors

The whole issue of hold harmless, indemnity, and insurance requirements in contracts is an ongoing battle for risk managers. With the introduction of a new ISO additional insured endorsement and a change in the definition of what constitutes an insured contract, all you thought you might know about the subject is changing. Here is what you must know.


It is assumed by many policyholders that whenever the Insurance Services Office, Inc. (ISO) announces it is “clarifying original intent,” the result will be a reduction in coverage. ISO recently (in December 2003 and in March 2004) announced that it is introducing substantially revised additional insured endorsements as well as-a revised “insured contract” definition. Such changes have the potential to wreak havoc on an already complex and chaotic area of contractual indemnity and additional insured law. While the new ISO endorsements ostensibly are meant to address the insurance industry’s perception that courts have been extending additional insured coverage beyond the drafting intent behind that coverage, the new ISO endorsements also may result in increased litigation-and restricted coverage to additional insureds and indemnitors.

It is common among contracting parties to assess the liability risk of contractual activities and seek the allocation of the economic risk of such liability in advance. Such allocation is most frequently done through a combination of
indemnity provisions and insurance procurement requirements. Subject to certain anti-indemnity statutes and wording requirements, most states allow parties to fully shift liability risk by allowing one party to agree to indemnify another party rather than rely upon the application of common law liability allocation rules. Indemnitors often are more willing to take on such indemnity obligations because the indemnitor relies upon its contractual liability coverage for those “insured contracts.”

However, because even the most well-written indemnification provisions are only as good as the assets that the indemnitor has available to satisfy its obligations, indemnitees frequently require that they also be made additional insureds on the indemnitor’s liability policy. But this indemnity/insurance approach to contractual risk transfer is subject to a maze of statutory restrictions and has generated an enormous amount of widely varying, and frequently irreconcilable, court decisions. Indemnitors, indemnitees, insurers, and the courts have all struggled with the intent behind, and the enforceability of, indemnity provisions. Such a task is made even more difficult where parties have economic incentives to modify their intent and to create ambiguities where none would otherwise exist when large losses occur. Some
courts have been similarly guilty in engaging in result-driven interpretations of indemnity provisions to maximize financial compensation for a victim, despite the parties’ clear mutual contracting intent. These complex interpretation problems have not been limited to contractual indemnity provisions. Contracting parties and their respective insurers also have struggled with the rights of, and scope of
coverage for, additional insureds. As might be expected, the additional insured generally wants to transfer as much of its liability as possible onto the additional
insured carrier and avoid implicating its own coverage. At the same time, the insurer generally wants to construe the additional insured’s coverage
rights as narrowly as possible and to offset its obligations by seeking contribution from the additional insured’s own insurance program.
Outside of construction-related contracts and subject to wording requirements, the majority of states allow parties to broadly shift liability prior to a loss through
indemnity provisions. Further, most courts have construed additional- insured coverage broadly to
encompass not just vicarious or joint negligence, but the additional insured’s sole negligence as well. In response to this majority trend and significant insurance industry exposure, ISO introduced several
new additional insured endorsements and a new “insured contract” definition earlier last year.
Specifically, ISO introduced ten revised additional insured endorsements: CG 2007 01 96 (Engineers, Architects, or Surveyors), CG 20 10 10 01 (Owners,
Lessees,or Contractors as Scheduled),
CG 20 15 11 88 (Vendors), CG 2026 11 85 (Designated Persons or Organizations) CG 20 33 1001 (Automatic Status When Required in Contracts for Owners, Lessees, and Contractors),
CG 203403 97 (Automatic Status When Required in Contracts for Equipment Lessors), and CG 2037 1001 (Completed Operations). Finally, -ISO introduced a new form, CG 242606 04, which seeks to amend the standard ISO-CGL’s “insured contract” definition.

Additional insureds should be wary of the use of the new ISO additional insured endorsements, particularly where their risk management programs rely heavily upon their contractors or vendors being fully responsible for the entire risk associated with a project. Further, additional insureds can expect insurers to become increasingly aggressive in trying to characterize losses as arising from the additional insured’s sole negligence, potentially pitting insureds against each other while an underlying claim is pending. Finally, indemnitors who frequently enter into broad form indemnity agreements must make sure those indemnity obligations remain “insured contracts.”
These new endorsements should cause warning bells to sound for named insureds, additional insureds, indemnitors, and indemnitees alike. While ISO’s intent to limit the insurance industry’s exposures through these endorsements is clear, it is less clear whether these new endorsements will clarify these complex issues or, rather, simply result in more coverage disputes.

New Bankruptcy Act

The Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act of 2005 was signed into law on April 20, 2005. It largely deals with consumer debt, but several provisions affect em­ployee benefits and executive compensation. The act improves protection from creditors for employee contributions to plans and for interest in retirement and education savings plans. It extends the avoidance period for fraudulent pre-petition transfers from one year to two. The act allows bankruptcy courts to throw out plan changes made within 180 days of the bankruptcy petition. It also significantly limits payments to plan insiders after a bankruptcy petition.

Wednesday, November 09, 2005

Easy To Be Hard

A great line from the musical "Hair." For fiduciaries and plan administrators the words "easy" or "free," should sound loud warning bells. Over two years ago, we warned against pension and fiduciary plan consultants wearing multiple hats, and this year there came subsequent and similar warnings by the SEC and the Department of Labor about consultants and conflicts of interest. ( see articles posted at www.mclaughlin-online.com) Yet, despite the warnings, plan administrators and fiduciaries continue to fall prey to "consultants" who offer to make their job easy by offering "one stop shopping."

Now we are even seeing a few insurance carriers trying to sell coverage directly to plans. Don't fall into that trap! Would you buy Enron stock direct from Ken Lay? As a pension fund trustee or administrator are you comfortable reading a fiduciary insurance policy and understanding the coverage it affords and more importantly, exclusion language contained in multiple endorsements. I can assure you your Fund's lawyer is not and will say so. Lawyers are good at raising questions but cannot give you an interpretation of how a policy will respond. An insurance company will give the interpretation, "the policy speaks for itself." An experienced Independent Insurance Agent specializing in Fund coverages can help you walk through this minefield of "whereas and wherefors" and if he/she is wrong carries E&O coverage to back up their work. Next time a "consultant" offers to sell your plan insurance ask for a copy of their insurance errors and omissions policy and state insurance license. You may be in for a surprise.

Most insurance companies cannot sell fiduciary coverages directly to Plans without violating their agreements with their agents. Besides they have only one incentive and that is to get your business. They have no incentive to "canvass the marketplace" or "explain the coverages or exclusions."

Plan trustees take their fiduciary responsibilities very seriously as they should. Be careful, even when someone you trust offers to get you insurance for "free" or "commission free." A fundamental tenant of risk management is "don't risk a lot for a little." Obtaining insurance coverage for your plan or yourself without a licensed, insured, expert independent agent is violating that tenant.

Independent Insurance Agents add value and protection to Plans. Don't let someone try to convince you otherwise by giving you a "free toaster." If you do, you may end up "burnt toast."

Revision to DeMinimus Standard for LM-30's

FORM LM-30 ADVISORY - DE MINIMIS EXEMPTION INCREASED

The Form LM-30 (Union Officer and Emolovee Report) informs filers that they “do not have to report any sporadic or occasional gifts, gratuities, or loans of insubstantial value, given under circumstances and terms unrelated to the [filer’s] status in a labor organization.” (Form LM-30 Instructions, General Instructions.) This test has been referred to as a “de minimis exemption.” If the test is satisfied, the filer need not report the gift or gratuity on Form LM-30. If the test is not satisfied, the gift or gratuity must be reported on Form LM-30.

Guidance previously issued by the Office of Labor-Management Standards (OLMS) on “de minimis” situations included examples of an employer picking up a lunch tab or an employer giving a union officer a Christmas gift of nominal value. A car was given as an example of a gift that would require a report. In March 2005, in order to provide more guidance on this issue, OLMS revised its LMRDA Interpretative Manual to quantify as “de minimis” an item with a value of $25 or less.

Between March and October 2005, because of a grace period, Form LM-30 reporting increased dramatically compared to historical practice. Based on a review of these reports, and considering comments from union officers and employees that the de minimis threshold was too low, OLMS has concluded that setting the reporting threshold at $25 places an unnecessary reporting burden on union officials without a corresponding benefit to union members or the public. As an interim measure, pending issuance of a final rule establishing revised Form LM-30 reporting obligations, OLMS has determined that gifts, gratuities or loans with a value of $250 or less received by a union officer or employee will be considered insubstantial for the purposes of Form LM-30 reporting. However, if the aggregate value of multiple gifts or loans from a single employer to a single union officer or employee exceeds $250 in a fiscal year, the transaction will no longer be treated as “de minimis,” and the aggregate value of the transactions will be reportable. Gifts or loans from multiple employees of one employer should be treated as originating from a single employer when calculating whether the $250 threshold has been exceeded.

Although offers of numerous small gratuities would appear to be outside the de minimis exemption because they are not provided on an “infrequent or sporadic” basis, the Department will not seek to enforce the reporting requirement, so long as the aggregate value of these gratuities does not exceed $250 per union officer or employee. For example, a union officer or employee who receives coffee, provided by an employer, at bi-weekly meetings over the course of a year would not be required to report this gratuity on a Form LM-30.

In a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking, published in the Federal Register on August 29, 2005, concerning the Form LM-30, the Department has sought comment on this standard and the dollar threshold. (70 Fed. Reg. 51166, 51175.) The comment period has been extended to January 26, 2006. (70 Fed. Reg. 61,400.) The Department encourages comments from all members of the public on all aspects of this rulemaking.




Last Updated: 11/07/05

Tuesday, November 08, 2005

Employment Related Practices Insurance

In case, you have been putting off talking to your Independent Insurance Agent about that Employment related practices insurance or Union liability insurance he/she has been recommending consider the following:

1. 1991 “Tailhook” convention —— $ 8 million to settle allegations of physical and verbal sexual abuse

2. State Farm —— $157 million to 800 staff employees to settle allegations of failure to pronlote and denial of opportunity

3. IDS Financial Services -- $ 35 million to 32 former employees to settle age discrimination allegations

4. Shoney’s -- $134 million out-of-court settlement arising from race discrimination allegations



Employment Related claims

1. Three of five businesses will be sued this year by an employee or a former
employee over an employment practice

41.5% of all claims-- employers of’ 15 to 100
23.9% of all claims -— employers of 500 or more
18.0% of’ all claims -- employers of’ 101 to 499
16.6% of all claims-- employers of less than 15

2. Employment practices suits account for 20% of all Federal Court filings

3. 56% of all employment practice filings going to trial result in a verdict for the plaintiff employee

4. The average jury award is S250.000, with 15% exceeding $1 million

5. 33% of wrongful termination verdicts have punitive damages equal to or exceeding compensatory damage.

Here are just a few sources of Liability for Employment Related Practices



• Civi1 Rights Act of 1964

• Civil Rights Act of 1991
• Americans With Disabilities Act (ADA)
• Age Discrimination in Employment Act of 1967 (ADEA)

• Worker Adjustment and Retraining Act (WARN)
• Employee Polygraph Protection Act of 1988
• Equal Pay Act
• Older Worker Benefit Protection Act

• National Labor Relations Act

• Uniform Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act of 1994
• Family and Medical Leave Act (FM LA)
• Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA)
• Immigration Reform and Control Act

• Occupational Safety and Health Act (OSHA)
• Civil Rights Act of 1866
• Attorneys Fees Award Act of 1976

• Pregnancy Discrimination Act of’ 1978

• State parallel laws
• Local parallel laws

Next time take a few minutes to discuss this with your Independent Insurance Agent.

Tuesday, November 01, 2005

Non-Profit Executive Compensation

Do you have friends who serve as directors on boards of nonprofit hospitals, charities, social welfare organizations, other 501(c)(3) or 501(c)(4) organizations or foundations who are responsible for determining executive compensation? Please warn them about the new, aggressively funded IRS and state audits of nonprofit executive compensation. Those responsible for approving remuneration now face potential personal liability if found to have negligently determined excessive compensation packages (IRC § 4958).

The IRS is staffing offices and adding personnel to question excessively high-paying nonprofit organizations. And many state Attorney General offices are now actively reviewing their state-chartered nonprofit and not-for-profit corporations (New York and California both have new laws specifically focused on reasonable and/or “just” pay).


The IRS basically defines reasonable compensation as average compensation, and half of all tax-exempt executives are paid “above average.” That may be OK, but only if you have a documented rationale for higher compensation levels, including an independent competitive compensation analysis.


If you have anything to do with executive compensation at a nonprofit, educate your Board, CEO/Executive Director and CFO before it is too late. Here are easy steps you can take:
Tax-Exempt Survey Data: Subscribe to the survey that the IRS, the State AG Office of New York and others use to define reasonable compensation.

Online Nonprofit Executive Compensation Data: Smaller organizations can use the SalaryExpert.com executive compensation report for organizations with less than $1 million in revenue.

Compensation Committee Certification: Treasury regulations on intermediate sanctions imply that using good data is not enough if your Board members are not competent to use it. Encourage compensation committee members to become certified in executive pay oversight.

Finally, make sure you and your friends sit only on Boards that have D&O Insurance. Many organizations will try and convince you this is not a expense the organization needs or can afford. As a Board member you can't afford not to have it or comprable coverage.

Personal Umbrella Policy Continued

Work-Related home premises liability is liability for injuries to those coming on your premises for business purposes, such as a courier bringing a package from your employer, who falls on your premises and sues for their injuries. Homeowner policies completely exclude business-related lawsuits. These are people that either have home businesses or bring business home to work.

This is one of the most overlooked exposures not covered by homeowner’s policies. This coverage under an umbrella policy sometimes is provided only if there is underlying coverage on the homeowners and sometimes even if underlying coverage is added to the homeowners, the umbrella will not extend unless you ask for and pay for additionally a separate incidental office endorsement to the umbrella policy.

Employer’s liability is coverage for clients with domestic workers (nannies, handyman, personal care attendants); this exposure is completely excluded by underlying policies. It is available through some umbrella policies sometimes requiring underlying primary coverage or sometimes as a freestanding coverage not requiring underlying coverage at all.

Many times an individual assumes liability when they sign a contract. At times the exposure is a huge and assumed unwittingly. Here are some examples:

1. An individual has an elevator installed in his/her home. The contract with the elevator maintenance company requires the individual to defend and pay judgments against them even when the cause of the injury was at least partially caused by the negligence of the elevator maintenance company.

2. A wedding reception contract contains a restaurant requirement that the bride and groom defend and pay judgments against the restaurant even if caused by the negligence of the restaurant (i.e., 100 guests getting seriously ill from food poisoning).

3. A group of friends, all turning 30 years old, rent a building for a birthday party. In the contract, one of the friends agrees to defend and pay any judgment the building owner for injuries or property damage regardless of who was at fault.

Each of these examples represent a liability exposure that is largely uninsured by primary liability coverage. Many of these exposures are excluded by some umbrella policies but are covered by others. To properly manage risk, the Independent agent must first determine what liability risks your client faces that are not insured by his primary policies. Then locate an umbrella policy or policies that best covers as many of these uninsured risks as possible.

Tuesday, October 25, 2005

Personal Umbrella Policy

Most people buy a personal umbrella policy for its excess coverage, including defense costs. It also has significant value as a risk management tool.


Often there are liability coverage gaps that fall outside the scope of underlying auto, homeowners, and other personal policies. An Independent agent can assist you in recommending an umbrella policy that provides step-down primary coverage for those uninsured exposures.

There is a lack of consistency among umbrella policies. Most personal auto and homeowners policies, are fairly comparable, umbrella policies vary dramatically in their coverage.

For the next few blogs we are going to explore how the right umbrella policy can help an individual obtain coverage for which is normally excluded. For today we are going to discuss automobile exposures.


For individuals who have no personal auto policy of their own and thus have no automatic coverage to drive non-owned cars (they either have no automobiles at all or only have a vehicle furnished by their employer) the purchase of the right umbrella policy may be the way to go. Underlying drive other car or named non-owner coverage is very expensive or unavailable, thus it may be most economical to choose an umbrella policy that will provide step-down coverage.

Certain individuals neither own nor drive their own car and are elderly or disabled. However they may receive rides through the generosity of their friends or family members to shop, see doctors, etc. Under many states principal-agency law, these passengers can be sued and held liable for accidents caused by their drivers because the car that caused the accident was on the road for the sole benefit of the passenger. Again, these individuals can avoid this exposure with an umbrella policy that does not require underlying insurance for this exposure.

Those individuals who are either furnished or have access to a company vehicle and occasionally have coworkers as passengers, umbrella coverage is desirable. If the driver’s negligence injures a coworker, the business auto policy usually excludes coverage for “fellow employee” lawsuits. The driver’s personal auto policy excludes coverage for vehicles “furnished or available for regular use.”

Under most personal auto policies, your collision coverage will transfer on an excess basis to a rental car, but only if you have collision coverage on at least one car. There is no coverage outside the United States and Canada. The right umbrella policy will cover collision damage you cause to a rented or borrowed car on a primary basis and worldwide.

Sometimes an individual signs a fine print contract to defend and pay any judgment against the rental car company, even if you weren’t personally driving the vehicle! (An example would be renting a vehicle on a business trip with a co-worker where you sign the rental contract solely, and the coworker causes the accident with injuries. The obligation is to defend and pay judgments against the rental company even though the signer had nothing to do directly with the accident. This is another instance where the right umbrella policy will protect an individual from an exposure the person doesn’t know exists.

Again, the right umbrella is something an individual should discuss with the person’s Independent Insurance Agent.

Wednesday, October 05, 2005

No Good Deed Goes Unpunished

One of Ted Pappas’s, The McLaughlin Company’s President, favorite quotes rings very true to people who elect to serve on not-for-profit boards of directors.

According to a survey by consultants Tillinghast, 96% of the claims brought against non­profit groups are from employ­ees, compared with 23% against public companies. Nonprofit boards are now being held more accountable, just like cor­porate directors. The Internal Revenue Service has stepped up scrutiny of private founda­tions, auditing 400 of them this federal fiscal year (ending Sept. 30), more than double that of recent years. The Department of Labor has beefed up their investigative and audit staffs targeting Labor Unions. The Senate Finance Committee held hearings in April about the oversight of tax-exempt organizations.

Many directors of the nation’s over 1 million charities, labor unions, and other nonprofits are clueless that they have the same fiduciary duties as corporate board members. “If they make a bad decision, someone can come after them,” warns Jeffrey Klenk, senior vice president at St. Paul Travelers, which sells directors and officers (D&O) liability insurance to nonprofits. “It might cost you up to $200,000 from out of your own pocket defending a lawsuit”

One management consultant and investment banker who joined the board of a non-profit agency giving job training to the disadvantaged and the disabled found his charitable impulse landed him in a lawsuit filed by 100 employees seeking unpaid wages. He was aghast to learn that his board had been fed false reports of glowing financial health—and startled to find that he was personally liable. The agency’s coffers were bare, so the only ones left to pay were the directors. The board ended up settling with the workers for $355,000 in back pay and $88,000 in attorneys’ fees.

Luckily for the board, its insurer covered both. Most non-profits are uninsured for such claims. The direc­tors also had to do much of the closing-down work. The consultant spent 600 hours of his time over two years on such chores as filing back payroll and sales tax forms.

Prior to joining a charitable board make sure that fellow directors and the staff are diligent and competent. Then investigate the extent of your group’s D&O policy, should there be one. If one doesn’t exist, contact an independent insurance agent to buy some coverage. Aside from Travelers, nonprofit D&O policies are available from Chubb, Hartford and American International Group. For Unions, both AIG and Ullico offer a Union Liability Policy specifically designed by The McLaughlin Company that covers those unique exposures arising from the Landrum-Griffin and Taft- Hartley Act. Many not-for-profit entities try to save money by telling their Boards that such coverage is not needed. This statement should be a “red flag” and an indication that someone is being “pennywise and pound foolish.”

If all else fails, you may be covered under your stan­dard homeowners and umbrella policy. Talk to your independent agent like The McLaughlin Company about more than your car and homeowners insurance. Let him/her help you identify exposures that you haven’t even thought about, especially those good deeds that “never go unpunished.”